February 6th, 2009
The Role of Evaluation in Autism Spectrum Intervention
Caroline I. Magyar, Ph.D., Division of Neurodevelopmental & Behavioral Pediatrics, University of Rochester School of Medicine & Dentistry

Student assessment and program evaluation are essential to identifying, selecting and evaluating effective interventions and educational programs for students with an autism spectrum disorder (ASD). As the number of children classified as autistic increases, school personnel can benefit from increasing their understanding of the role that evaluation plays in determining student instructional needs and designing and evaluating effective programs and interventions. Evaluation provides the data needed to design appropriate and effective instructional contexts that promote student learning and achievement, goals of our federal laws (IDEA, 2004; NCLB, 2001).

Students with ASD are a heterogeneous group presenting with a wide range of neurodevelopmental deficits and high rates of learning and behavior disorders; all of which can challenge their ability to access the general education curriculum, engage in the instructional process, and participate in the least restrictive environment. With features of the disorder affecting multiple developmental areas and symptoms varying in severity across students and across the age span, school personnel need to routinely evaluate the unique learner characteristics and instructional needs of each of their students. In addition, the instructional context (e.g., curriculum, instruction, positive behavior supports) also needs to be routinely evaluated in order to identify and provide effective interventions and supports.

It is only when the instructional context is aligned with the student’s instructional level and contains the appropriate social and behavior supports that he/she will learn. While this might seem the sole responsibility of the individual teacher or therapist, school administrators need to ensure that district infrastructure supports educational personnel in the use of these evidence-based practices. Therefore, formalized on-going program evaluation is a necessary component in all districts wishing to ensure that their students are achieving. This requires a commitment by the school district to ensure that its policies and procedures support school personnel in gaining the knowledge, skill and ability to engage in meaningful student evaluation that allows for the identification of the student’s instructional needs, identification and application of appropriate interventions, progress monitoring, and evaluation of the student’s response to the intervention.

Because educational programs and/or interventions derived and evaluated in the context of research do not always translate to the field, student and program level evaluation are necessary to demonstrate that a district and its personnel are applying effective practices. Evaluation should, therefore, become a part of the daily repertoire of all school personnel. Successful ASD programming requires school leaders to understand the needs of their students, create school contexts that contain elements of effective practice in ASD education, and policy and procedures that ensure research-based elements are translated into practice to improve student outcome.

Evaluation provides the data that are needed to make informed decisions about student and district programs and to assist with problem-solving for those programs, interventions or practices that are ineffective. Please join our talk scheduled for 8:30 am on March 7th to hear me discuss the fundamental role that evaluation plays in evidenced-based practice in ASD education, and the issues and considerations in designing appropriate student assessment and program evaluation protocols.

bookmark    print    email    comments (2)

(3 votes)
Loading ... Loading ...
2 responses
Rose Stilson -- February 11th, 2009 at 10:32 pm

I agree that the educational evaluation and programming is the biggest contributing factor in the success or failure of a child to reach his maximum potential.
My son is truly undisputable evidence of this. He had the support and programming he needed from preschool through high school and without further intervention, was able to meet the challenges of a university on his own. He is about to graduate from the university with a 3.3? and a job in finance! “He has reached higher levels than anyone I have ever worked with” says his past teachers, principal, and therapists. His story should be told. He really has beet Autism!
If there is anyway he could attend the March conference as a contributor or volunteer, he is available. Please let us know if you have any scholarships to attend.
Thanks,
Rose Stilson

Cathy -- May 1st, 2009 at 11:08 am

Please send me any extra info on assessments for asd, I work in a charter and would love tools that would help me to assess and work with/track my students. I would love hints that would help them to grow and develop more. Most of these children who end up with me are with parents who have denial syndrom, and won’t let the student be tested. Any helps for them to succeed would be a benefit for them, as well as the class as a whole. I hope each child is able to be all that they can be ….. thanks in advance

post a comment
Your Privacy Matters
Please note that the Thirteen/WNET editorial staff reserves the right to not post comments it deems to be inappropriate and/or malicious in nature, as well as edit comments for length, clarity and fairness. No solicitations or advertisements will be allowed. Users may link to other Web sites relevant to discussion, but most often links to commercial Web sites will not be permitted.


Produced by THIRTEEN    ©2010 Educational Broadcasting Corporation. All rights reserved.